December 6, 2023

The hand-brain connection is stronger once we write one thing by hand vs. typing it

Article content material

Aisha Attah used to put in writing by hand rather a lot, whether or not for schoolwork or in her journal. However after the pandemic started, Attah, 20, discovered herself spending extra time on-line – and fewer with a pen and paper.

Months later, in a gathering at her first job, Attah tried taking notes by hand. “It was extremely uncomfortable,” mentioned Attah, a model advertising and marketing government in Southampton, England.

Commercial 2

Article content material

Article content material

Handwriting is a tremendous motor ability that isn’t innately discovered; it must be taught and practiced. It is also a ability that advantages us by stimulating our mind: We bear in mind info higher once we write it down by hand, analysis exhibits.

However for many people, handwriting can really feel tough as we flip to smartphones, different units and even robots for a lot of of our hand duties.

And with cursive dropped from Frequent Core State Requirements in 2010 in the US, youngsters have few alternatives to be taught and apply; for some, handwriting has been relegated to an extracurricular exercise.

The issue isn’t solely that we’re working towards much less. Know-how has modified the best way we use our fingers. Additionally, the extra time we spend on our units, the higher the likelihood of issues with our fingers and wrists, reminiscent of ache, weak spot and nerve modifications.

“It’s like going to the gymnasium,” mentioned Mellissa Prunty, an occupational therapist at Brunel College London and chair of the Nationwide Handwriting Affiliation in the UK. “Once you write for lengthy intervals of time however you don’t do it typically, you’re going to really feel drained and fatigued.”

Commercial 3

Article content material

– – –

Why handwriting issues

The hand-brain connection is stronger once we write one thing by hand vs. typing it, mentioned Paula Heinricher, an occupational therapist and nationwide presenter for Studying With out Tears, which trains educators in topics, together with handwriting. Though we’d have the ability to take extra notes on a keyboard than by hand, “there’s additionally analysis that exhibits once you write by hand, there’s a deeper mind connection and a deeper understanding, and you keep that info longer,” she mentioned.

A 2020 meta-analysis concluded that school college students carried out worse of their courses after they typed notes into a tool vs. writing them by hand. And a 2014 examine discovered that college students who took notes by hand understood the knowledge higher than those that used laptops for word taking.

The flexibility to put in writing rapidly and legibly additionally has a crucial hyperlink with tutorial efficiency. A 2013 examine discovered that youngsters who had good handwriting expertise in preschool carried out higher in studying and math in second grade. And in a 2019 examine of 141 first-graders in 4 colleges in Italy, youngsters who have been taught cursive developed higher studying and writing expertise in contrast with a management group.

Article content material

Commercial 4

Article content material

Prunty has labored with youngsters who’ve above-average studying, spelling and vocabulary expertise. However due to tremendous motor coordination difficulties, “these youngsters, though they’re brilliant, will write much less, and it’s much less fascinating to learn. That’s as a result of their velocity is impacted,” she mentioned.

– – –

Fewer tremendous motor actions

If our hand muscle tissue don’t really feel significantly sprightly, it’s simple to level the finger at our units: We ship a textual content as an alternative of writing a word. Or we kind a grocery record into an app reasonably than scrawling it by hand.

Whereas there may be little exhausting proof that fewer college students are taking notes or finishing assignments by hand now in contrast with years previous, youngsters’s use of units has elevated, particularly within the pandemic years, mother and father mentioned.

However units aren’t the one perpetrator. On the whole, we’re not partaking in as many tremendous motor actions as up to now, mentioned Ritu Goel, a licensed hand therapist on the College of Maryland Medical Heart.

With keyless entry, as an illustration, many people now not flip a key to unlock our automobile or the entrance door; as an alternative, we push a button or faucet out a code. So the lateral pinch, a tremendous motor movement, “is turning into rather less utilized in day-to-day exercise,” Goel mentioned.

Commercial 5

Article content material

– – –

The results of gadget overuse

Overuse of expertise can impact our handwriting muscle tissue; the principle ones being the flexor pollicis longus, the flexor digitorum superficialis and the flexor digitorum profundus. The flexor pollicis longus permits us to flex the thumb, whereas the opposite muscle tissue enable for finger flexion. We additionally use these muscle tissue for different tremendous motor duties reminiscent of choosing up small objects.

In a small 2015 examine of scholar smartphone customers, researchers discovered that the flexor pollicis longus tendon – which originates as a muscle within the forearm – was bigger on members’ dominant aspect than the non-dominant aspect. That was true for all members, no matter how a lot they used their smartphones.

The dimensions distinction, although, was largest in those that used their units probably the most. In that very same excessive utilization group, the median nerve – a sensory and motor nerve starting on the armpit and ending on the fingers – was considerably bigger on the dominant aspect than the non-dominant aspect.

Researchers theorized that smartphone overuse precipitated the variations. With the repetitive pinching movement of texting, “just one muscle is doing actually exhausting work,” mentioned examine writer Esra Erkol Inal, affiliate professor of bodily remedy and rehabilitation at Reyap Hospital Istanbul. There’s no profit to utilizing one a part of the hand so extensively, Inal mentioned, however there are dangers.

Commercial 6

Article content material

Overworking particular muscle tissue can enlarge tendons sufficient to trigger noticeable signs. The tendons controlling our fingers start as muscle tissue within the forearm and run out to our fingertips by the tight area of the carpal tunnel. Greater tendons crowd the median nerve, which primarily will get squished, mentioned Lisa Kruse, a hand surgeon and assistant professor of orthopedics and rehabilitation on the College of Wisconsin College of Medication and Public Well being. The end result: carpal tunnel syndrome, which causes numbness, ache and weak spot within the hand and forearm.

A examine of neurology sufferers at a Turkish college discovered that folks recognized with carpal tunnel syndrome spent extra hours per day on their smartphones than these with out hand or wrist complaints.

Grip energy – which permits us to carry a pen or pencil – might also be affected: A small examine of scholars at a college in Lahore, Pakistan, discovered a major affiliation between excessive ranges of smartphone utilization and a weaker grip.

Whereas extra analysis is required, it’s attainable that the extra we use our cell units, the upper the danger for some kind of hand dysfunction. System overuse modifications the steadiness of our hand muscle tissue and will trigger injury sooner or later, Inal mentioned.

Commercial 7

Article content material

We apologize, however this video has didn’t load.

– – –

Assist for handwriting muscle tissue

Whilst we proceed to make use of expertise and units, we will bolster our handwriting muscle tissue with just a few methods.

Be sure your smartphone isn’t too huge. If our smartphone is massive relative to our hand, we wind up reaching throughout it extra, which may trigger thumb ache, Goel mentioned. It is best to have the ability to maintain your smartphone comfortably in a single hand with a very good grasp.

Use units mindfully: Her teenage sufferers scoff, however Goel advises texting with the index finger – not thumbs – whereas holding the smartphone within the different hand. Give your self cues to take breaks from scrolling, reminiscent of by setting alarms in your telephone. And don’t neglect posture: When working at a desk, Inal shops her telephone in a smartphone stand and strives to maintain herself vertical, reasonably than hunched over.

Stretch and strengthen: In case your fingers are cramping, Goel recommends tendon gliding workout routines, actions to bend and straighten completely different joints. You may also carry out what’s referred to as a prayer stretch by bringing your palms collectively together with your elbows out and pointing your fingertips upward for a wrist extension. Reverse the train with a wrist flexion, directing your fingertips down so the backs of your fingers contact. As well as, Goel suggests rolling your fingers throughout therapeutic putty, Play-Doh or a small rolling pin.

Commercial 8

Article content material

Finishing duties with out assistive units will assist strengthen the small stabilizing muscle tissue in your fingers. For example, utilizing a guide can opener engages your gripping and pinching muscle tissue, Kruse mentioned. One strengthening train she suggests: Place your hand on its pinkie finger aspect on a floor. Carry your index finger upward to interact the dorsal interosseous muscle, positioned between your thumb and index finger. Work towards including resistance, reminiscent of a rubber band.

When unsure, get it checked out: In case you have hand, wrist or forearm discomfort that interferes with every day actions, search a medical analysis. An occupational or bodily therapist can carry out an ergonomic evaluation to establish any problematic environmental elements – a workstation set too excessive, for instance, Goel mentioned. Generally hand fatigue is said to author’s cramp, a sort of dystonia or involuntary muscle contractions, which might be handled.

Handwriting, typing and even dictation-to-text strategies are all worthwhile methods to precise ourselves. And whereas it’s not lifelike or essential to keep away from our units, it’s value bringing again that handwritten word every so often and inspiring your youngsters to do the identical, Heinricher mentioned.

“The fact is that we’re a hybrid world. So it’s about having completely different instruments in your literacy toolbox,” Prunty mentioned.

For extra well being information and content material round ailments, circumstances, wellness, wholesome dwelling, medication, therapies and extra, head to – a member of the Postmedia Community.

Article content material


Postmedia is dedicated to sustaining a energetic however civil discussion board for dialogue and encourage all readers to share their views on our articles. Feedback might take as much as an hour for moderation earlier than showing on the positioning. We ask you to maintain your feedback related and respectful. We have now enabled e mail notifications—you’ll now obtain an e mail when you obtain a reply to your remark, there may be an replace to a remark thread you comply with or if a person you comply with feedback. Go to our Neighborhood Pointers for extra info and particulars on learn how to modify your e mail settings.

    Commercial 1